Wednesday, April 29th, 2009 Kara Vs. Paula: Who Should Stay? With episodes running late and rumors of backstage drama, it’s hard to believe that both Kara DioGuardi and Paula Abdul will be around for the next season of American Idol. But which one should go? The producers didn’t tell the other judges about DioGuardi’s addition before the season started, and most believe the goal was to push Abdul out. “Despite what everyone tells you … and they’re all denying it, they want her off the show,” an insider told the Chicago Sun-Times last week. “Everyone’s tired of her bizarre and always unpredictable behavior and temper tantrums.” But the veterans are closing ranks. In a new TV Guide interview, Simon Cowell says “I’ve always made it clear that I wouldn’t like to do the show without [Abdul, Ryan Seacrest and Randy Jackson]. I would fight for any of them.” Meanwhile, anyone can tell Randy’s tired of having to shout over two women to Simon. Something has to change! Are you tired of Paula’s rambling, or is Kara even worse? Which one do you want to see around next year? Posted by Anthony Miccio at 4:41 pm American Idol Poll celebrity feud Idol Gossip Paula Abdul Kara DioGuardi
Comments
36 Responses to “Kara Vs. Paula: Who Should Stay?”
this outrageous
paula is loved by everyoneand for this new judge to come tryt and ruin that (well she’s nothing but a butt head) i don’t like her and i saw her singing at the mtv awards
she can’t sing she sounds like a crying dogg
dummie head. I think that kara should definitely leave
Desperate news day: fabricate some drama.
With Paula as a judge we don’t know what to expect or what she will say. Those type of antics. regardless of a boring week of Idol singers, keep Idol on everyone’s lips the next morning at the water cooler.
[...] like the Kara vs. Paula battle may have a winner already: Kara DioGuardi revealed to TV Guide that American Idol’s [...]
PAULA ALL THE WAY .
How is this even a question? The show would be boring without Paula. Kara’s droning just makes me want to fast forward.
paula needs to stay and she will, simon has said she will be on the show as long as he is on it
PAULA SHOULD STAY, OF COURSE.
~
((((((((((((((((((((((~PAULA ~ABDUL~:)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))~
show would be very boring without PAULA ABDUL. shes helped keep this show #1 for 8 years, its success has nothing to do with Kara. paula is staying
paula should stay. and she will. who cares what happens to kara. not me!
Paula, of course! If Paula leaves i’m done with AI. Kara just ruined the chemistry the three judges had! What a joke!!
Pleas the show is nothing without crazy Paula !
PAULA ALL THE WAY .
we love paula abdul !! she rox
Paula is just awesome! interesting character she’s like everybody a lil sane a lil cuckoolove crazy Paula!
I would really love to see a Randy vs Simon who should stay poll. I mean this is just ridiculous. I dont understand why the media keeps on creating drama where there is no drama. I like them all. If I had to choose I will pick Paula anyday.
PAULA PAULA PAULA <333333
Kara brings nothing to the show except for her rambling which makes me freaking annoyed. she definitely has to go!
Should there even be a contest between them. PAULA ALL THE WAY! Kara sucks bigtime.
Paula. Duh. She’s awesome.
And she can dance. A true Idol. Even if there are bad rumors circulating around her, she still can smile and enjoy her life. She may appear whacky on the show, but that’s what makes Idol so fun to watch 
Simon and Paula fooling around is wayyy better than kara’s “blah blah blah.” “heres the thing!” she CAN’T even COUNT. 
Paula is the Queen of Idol and she needs to stay!
Btw: why no polls Simon vs Randy? why only paula vs Kara? its because they are females and its annoying as hell. not all women hate each other! paula and kara got along amazing initially but the MEDIA has turned them against each other. the media has almost ruined their friendship.
idol would lose all its charm if paula left. i dont think she will leave though, thank god.
no paula? no show!
kara was not there to make the show what it is today, why should she come in and take credit?! not fair.
Paula is Queen
clearly Paula should stay. Kara needs to peace out!
I hope paula stays, Kara is really anoying!
I am going for PAULA all the way, but I hate these polls where they have to pit the girls against each other it doesnt make any sense to me. I have have never seen any poll pitting Randy against Simon. I think it’s all wrong.
I would still like to see Paula Abdul Stay. We all have problems, and I don’t think she is any different than any other person out there. I think she is a great person, just misunderstood. Leave her alone actually. Let her live. Like I said WE ALL ARE HUMAN and I Don’t see her being any different. Hell if it were Liz Taylor I would understand or Paris Hilton, but she has been there from day one.
Going on to Kara, I think she is great, but get’s pissy at times when it comes to finding people. Kara is very professional and I like her too, but Paula needs to stay….
That’s just my opinion!!
Kara calls someone a #(&(#&^`&((%##^`+ but she does not look into the mirror. That’s why.
I DONT THINK THAT PAULA NEEDS TO LEAVE THE SHOW. BUT FOR SURE HER AND SIMON NEED TO BE AWAY FROM EACH OTHER THE SHOW ISNT ABOUT THEM ITS ABOUT THE TALENT. THE WAY THAT PAULA AND SIMON CONDUCT THIERSELVES IS CHILDISH AND UNPROFESSIONAL. ITS A SHAME THEY NEED TO BE TREATED LIKE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL CHILDREN AND HAVE `@~!@+*@$`^+$&# IGNED SEATS. BUT I DO LIKE PAULA.
paula stays , kara needs to kick rocks and follow them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
PAULA WILL BE FOREVER OUR GIRL
Hi, good post. I have been wondering about this issue,so thanks for posting.
paulaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
i think paula should stay cuz shes my favorite and shes been here for so long i think it would be horrible for her to leave and kara is just an add to the show she doesnt really need to be on american idol!!!!!!!!! in my opinion!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
PAULA,dah the show would be boring with out her shes like the hall of fame when it comes to idol judging
Paula should def. stay on the show!! With Simon and Randy it’s a perfect mix. Sorry Kara, You’re very annoying!! Paula is real! I will take her as she is anyday.